Q4 : Role Distinctions between Men and Women
Please tell me what do these verses mean:
1Ti 2:12 But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over
the man, but to be in silence.
1Co 14:34 Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not
permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under
obedience, as also saith the law.
Tit 2:4-5 That they may teach the young women to be sober, to love their husbands, to love their children, to be discreet, chaste, keepers at home, good, obedient to their own husbands, that the word of God be not blasphemed.
|
A4 : by Tony Garland
All of the verses you are asking about share a common theme: it is God's
design that men be leaders, in society, in the church, and in the home.
The created order, even before sin entered into the picture, was that
man was created first and woman second as a help-meet.
A resource which would be very helpful for studying these verses in
detail is available freely on the internet:
Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood,
http://www.leaderu.com/orgs/cbmw/rbmw.
It can also be purchased online
as a booka.
I would recommend reading the detailed articles in the above book which
deal specifically with these passages within the overall context of
Scriptural teaching regarding manhood and womanhood. The book does an
excellent job of recognizing the teaching of Scripture regarding men and
women: their equality in standing, but difference in roles--both
domestically and in church leadership. I believe the articles in the
book are reliable and very comprehensive.
A good introductory resource on these passages is the MacArthur Study
Bible. I've included John MacArthur's summary comments on each passage
below. I believe they capture the essence of what is being said in each
context and in view of the overall teaching of Scripture on these
matters. (Don't be surprised to find what Scripture says to be miles
apart from the practice of many modern churches which have imbibed
deeply from the waters of secular feminism.)
1Ti 2:12-14 - Paul is forbidding women from filling the
office and role of the pastor or teacher. He is not prohibiting them
from teaching in other appropriate conditions and circumstances (cf.
Acts 18:26; Titus 2:3,4). Paul forbids women
from exercising any type of authority over men in the church assembly,
since the elders are those who rule (5:17). They are all to be men (as
is clear from the requirements in 3:2,5). in silence: Women are to be
silent by not teaching, and they are to demonstrate submission by not
usurping the authority of the pastors or elders.
1Co 14:34 - The principle of women not speaking in church
services is universal; this applies to all the churches, not just
locally, geographically, or culturally. The context in this verse
concerns prophecy, but includes the general theme of the chapter, i.e.,
tongues. Rather than leading, they are to be submissive as God's Word
makes clear (see notes on 11:3-15; Gen. 3:16; 1 Tim. 2:11-15). It is not
coincidental that many modern churches that have tongues-speaking and
claim gifts of healings and miracles also permit women to lead worship,
preach, and teach. Women may be gifted teachers, but they are not
permitted by God "to speak" in churches. In fact, for them to do so is
"shameful," meaning "disgraceful." Apparently, certain women were out of
order in disruptively asking questions publicly in the chaotic services.
Tit 2:4-5 - 2:4 admonish the young women. Their own examples of
godliness (v. 3) give older women the right and the credibility to
instruct younger women in the church. The obvious implication is that
older women must exemplify the virtues (vv. 4,5) that they "admonish."
love their husbands. Like the other virtues mentioned here, this one is
unconditional. It is based on God's will, not on a husband's worthiness.
The Greek word phileo emphasizes affection. See notes on Eph. 5:22-24.
2:5 discreet. I.e., pure. Cf. 1 Tim. 2:9-11,15; 1 Pet. 3:3-6.
homemakers. Cf. 1 Tim. 5:14. Keeping a godly home with excellence for
one's husband and children is the Christian woman's non-negotiable
responsibility. obedient. The ideas of radical feminism were an integral
part of ancient Babylonian and Assyrian mythology as well as of Greek
gnosticism, which flourished throughout the Roman Empire during NT times
and posed a constant danger to the early church. Modern feminism is
neither new nor progressive; it is age-old and regressive. See notes on
Eph. 5:22. not be blasphemed. This is the purpose of godly conduct-to
eliminate any reproach on Scripture. For a person to be convinced God
can save from sin, one needs to see someone who lives a holy life. When
Christians claim to believe God's Word but do not obey it, the Word is
dishonored. Many have mocked God and His truth because of the sinful
behavior of those who claim to be Christians. Cf. Matt. 5:16; 1 Pet.
2:9.
Our doctrinal statement also contains a section addressing this general
issue:
"We believe that in the body of Christ men and women stand
spiritually equal and constitute the Church universal. We believe women
have had and always will have their God-given gifts and roles within
this body. Accordingly, as the primary role of believing men is to be
husbands and fathers, so the primary role of women is to be wives and
mothers. But modern secular feminism has destroyed the importance of
these positions and blurred the differences between men and women. We
encourage women to have personal ministries. But the Scriptures are
clear that male leadership is called to the local church positions of
deacon, elder, and pastor-teacher. No amount of debate can water down
what the Bible says about the individual and distinct callings of both
sexes, in regard to gifts and positions. We equally encourage women to
pursue diplomas but the role of pastor-teacher is Biblically reserved
for men."
I hope this helps answer some of your questions. I highly recommend
reading the articles in the book I listed at the beginning of my reply.
It is an excellent treatment of the subject with carefully considered and
Scripturally solid discussion of all the issues related to this entire
subject area.
Links Mentioned Above
a - See http://www.bestbookdeal.com/booksearch?country=US&search=TTL&string=Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood.
|